Monday, July 2, 2012

Laying Down with Dogs

As many readers of this blog may be aware there is an old adage "He that lieth down with dogs shall rise up with fleas". As much as we see the truth in this everyday, one place that it is particularly appropriate is how this applies to headline news of the day. For instance, we see this: Mitt Romney to visit Israel. According to the Ynet Story:
Republican US presidential candidate Mitt Romney is planning a trip to Israel this summer, the New York Times reported on Monday.
An aide to Romney confirmed that a trip is being planned. No details were immediately available about exactly when and where the candidate will visit.... 
This will be Romney’s fourth visit to Israel. His first visit was on a Mormon Church trip, and his second visit was in 2007, when he served as a keynote speaker at the Herzliya Conference. In January 2011, Romney spent three days in Israel during a tour of the region.
So, Romney has been to Israel 3x in the past and as late as last January. Why the need to go back there in the middle of a campaign? Because Israel is a strong ally? Perhaps it would it be a cynical ploy to get Jewish voters in Florida and Pennsylvania to reconsider their vote? And while trying to influence Jewish voters, perhaps it would also be an attempt to shore up his support with Evangelical and Hard Right Voters who want nothing more than to bomb Iran and take the fight to "Teh Mooslims"?

Now on the surface, it is an interesting move. I mean President Obama has NOT made a visit to Israel
 (something I think he should do in his second term). And if he so much as casts an unsavory glance at Ron Prosser or Benyamin Netanyahu than the Republican noise machine kicks into high gear and with it's little army of ODS (Obama Derangement Syndrome) suffering drones they spread out through the Intertoobz whining and using the slighest excuse to portray President Obama as an enemy of Israel AND the Jewish People.

Now, if Romney's intention is to shore up his support with Jewish Americans (78% of whom voted for President Obama in 2008 - and still has a support the President at a rating of 15-20 pts. higher than the general American public) then this trip is an odd way to do it. Of course it has the cheap point that President Obama has not visited Israel but, that is a small issue. In fact if this is his reason, then it shows just how out of touch Romney is with the American Jewish Political Community. American Jews have always been at the forefront of the Liberal and Progressive movements. Our long history of oppression has taught us to use our political power to help society NOT to turn our back on it in some Randian frenzy of greed.

Jews voted for and support Democrats (and President Obama) because of this. Romney with this trip assumes Jewish Americans will vote for him because they care about Israel MORE than they care about their fellow countrymen/women and that his cheap publicity stunt will somehow prove this. NOT ONLY THAT, but it's a fail of a move politically. According to the AJC poll of 2012 only 4% of American Jews put Israel as their #1 priority when it comes to voting. Of course, in my mind those people that put another country ahead of their own should simply move there but that argument is for another day. With this cheap stunt Romney assumes the old "Dual Loyalty" canard. He assumes that our community will simply forget our liberal and progressive roots and will "lie down" with some trickster who's closest connection to Jewish people is converting dead Holocaust victims to the Church of Latter Day Saints.

In making this assumption, Republicans actually think Jewish voters are stupid enough (well some are dumb enough / uninformed enough to fall for this) that they will ignore the following glaring shortcomings of the Romney campaign.

  • Their candidate is dedicating his campaign to tearing down the new healthcare reform act that will provide 50 million more Americans with healthcare. Not to mention providing coverage to millions of people with pre-existing conditions and many other sweeping benefits.
  • The Republicans stand for gutting the Social Safety Net, including removing protections for seniors, and privatizing (because you know the Market is such a safe place for investors) their retirement accounts.
  • The Republicans further stand for gutting our environmental laws, drilling in protected areas, INCREASING our dependence on fossil fuels, denying climate change and a host of other horrible positions regarding the environment.
  • They ignore the fact that conservatives want to do away with important civil rights protections for all Americans including voting rights for African Americans, and marriage equality rights for Gay and Lesbian Americans. That Republicans are moving forward trying to get DOMA revisted.
These blockheads actually think that Jewish Americans would overlook ALL of this because Mitt Romney is making a trip to Israel and that President Obama did not make one. Somehow they think this will magically transform the Romney candidacy for Jewish voters and that all of a sudden Jewish voters will completely sellout their own political ideals and countrypeople because they secretly value Israel over America.

Of course, what they don't realize is that Jewish voters have every reason in the world to support President Obama and as President he has been one of Israel's and the Jewish people's greatest friends. See, it is not the little things, like the President ragged on PM Netanyahu, or that the U.S. didn't cast a veto at some point in time when the hard right would have liked him too. When push comes to shove the President has always, and I mean always been there for us.

He is the first President in the history of the U.S. to host and introduce Passover Seders to the White House. He is the first President in the history of the U.S. to name a month in honor of Jewish History. He has been a consistant supporter of all things Jewish in the U.S. and is knowlegable about our community and its needs.

As for Israel, well... I can't think of a better friend. He has increased U.S. aid to Israel. American aid pays for anti-Missle systems that save Israeli (both Jewish and Arab) lives. His administration has been huge in supporting the development of the Iron Dome, Magic Wand, and David's Sling anti-Missle defense. At the U.N. he has supported Israel up and down the line but really all of this is neither here nor there.

His domestic agenda MATCHES that of our general community. Just a short list of accomplishments:
  • The Affordable Care Act - which protects millions of Americans from calamity and provides benefits to almost every American.
  • Ending discrimmination against Gay and Lesbian soldiers and bravely speaking out in favor of marriage equality
  • Introducing sanity to our immigration issues and showing kindness to people who were otherwise outlaws due to no fault of their own
  • Increasing environmental standards for automobiles and working to develop American clean energy sources
  • Supporting Women's rights in the workplace
  • Defending the rights of the unemployed.
All of these things are what Mr. Romney and the ODS drones want us to ignore. Instead, they that some cheap photo op. will change peoples reality so that they don't see all of the good that President Obama has accomplished and instead will fall for a "one off" trick. But most people (with the exception of a few morons) see through this. Most people understand that if they "lie down" with the Republicans and vote for them they would wake up the next morning with a huge case of "fleas". They would wake up to an America that doesn't value it's citizens health, that doesn't value the environment or education or equal rights. They would wake up to an America that is nothing more than pursuit of individual greed.

This is why the American Jewish Community supports the President by much larger margins than the general populace. We know what this President means to us. We know the good things that he has accomplished for our country and as Americans that is what is most important. We are also thankful for his real and practical support of our brothers and sisters in Israel. How America's alliance with Israel has never been stronger. It is a nice bonus. Overall, we KNOW the President has "our back" as he has proven time and time again.

As a community we know we do not need lie down with the "dogs" to get what we want or need. We should continue on the high road and ignore the incesssant whining and actual bullshit that spews from the failure that is the right wing and the Republican Party.

7 comments:

  1. It isn't a play for Jewish votes. It is a play for evangelical enthusiasm.

    ReplyDelete
  2. (livosh1)
    Let's be clear. There is nothing wrong with a Presidential candidate visiting Israel. Obama did that in '08. The problem is that this is a cynical play for wacko conservatives, and therefore Willard is likely to only to spend time with Bibi & Co. and their supporters in the settlements. We should encourage Willard to also meet with opposition leaders, with representatives from the protest movement, with Arab citizens of Israel, and others. Of course, he won't do that. He wants to ensure that every last American with ODS goes to the polls on election day. Willard's problem is that there are simply not enough voters with ODS to put him over the top. They are loud and obnoxious, but their numbers are shrinking. And the real bigots among them probably won't vote for Romney either, because he is a Mormon.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well livosh... There is nothing wrong with a candidate visiting Israel - but I agree with you and wanted to point out that this is a cynical ploy for nut-jobs and droolers.

      I disagree with you in that, I don't think we should encourage Mitt to do anything. I think we should just leave him to his own devices and see what he comes up with.

      I think you are right though, in that this is a push for those American Jews who either wish they were Israeli (but don't have the courage to be Israeli) or for the Armchair Wingnut crowd who thinks they are Israeli and are at the frontlines in the fight against TEH EBLIZ MOOSLIMS...

      They are loud and obnoxious but they are also incredibly dumb and view the world through such a completely twisted lens that they render themselves meaningless.

      Delete
    2. (livosh1)
      Regarding encouraging Mitt: My point is that said encouragement would make a mockery of his visit to Israel. He is obviously going to do only that which will make him look good in the eyes of those with a bad case of ODS. The fact that he would not meet with diverse segments of Israeli society, and would not explore first-hand the many complexities that make Israel so incredibly unique, just shows how ridiculous his views on -- and attitudes toward -- Israel really are.

      Delete
  3. @ fizziks... How do you figure?

    I mean I get that he has to prove his right-wing evangelical "chops", but, I see this as something different.

    Think on it this way... There is not much he can say regarding Israel that President Obama has not said. Aside from a few drooling lunatics who are woefully ignorant of reality, he has nothing... EXCEPT for a visit to Israel itself and even more pandering to the Israeli Hard Right. I think he is trying to pick-up some votes in FL, and PA.

    Of course, he is relying on the assumption that Jewish voters are NOT as concerned with their own country but rather are first and foremost concerned with Israel. He assumes that despite ALL the good that President Obama has done for Israel, that Jewish voters will somehow see that he and his visit (when the President has not gone) will change our minds as to who our real friends are.

    ALSO, he is relying on the assumption that Jewish voters will simply toss away their liberal values and vote for him because they value Israel over their own country. Now that is true for some of the ODS crowd but, in general I think that is a bad assumption.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, I'm uncomfortable with the whole idea that some Jews are more concerned with Israel than they are with America. Israel is an important issue and it is ok if someone sees it as important. Not just because Israel is the Jewish state but because it is an important US strategic ally in the Middle East. It is quite ok to be concerned with Israel and shouldn't be stigmatized by framing as accusing someone of liking Israel or America more. In my opinion this language smacks of that employed by the IDS brigade.

      Now the reason that I think this is more a play for evangelicals than Jews is that Romney has a huge well-funded sophisticated poitical operation with all of the resources of the Republican establisgment at his disposal. The wonks in his employ have focused grouped things to death and know exactly what you have said in this posting - that Jewish voters are not likely to make a large difference to his candidacy. We will break largely for Obama and our minds are largely made up. But if Romney, rather than swinging maybe a few percentage points of an already tiny demographic group, can instead motivate millions of evangelicals to vote and dontate crucial bodies on election day, that actually makes a big difference.

      Jewish voters are going to break big for Obama, and peeling off a few percentage points of a group that is only a few percentage points of the population has a minisule effect. Romney's operation has to know this.

      Delete
    2. Thanks for the response.

      As for:

      Well, I'm uncomfortable with the whole idea that some Jews are more concerned with Israel than they are with America. Israel is an important issue and it is ok if someone sees it as important.

      I am not so uncomfortable with that because it is the truth. There are Jews who put Israeli interests over American ones. I know some of them. In all my years of engagement in various youth groups and political groups you see them. By no means are they a majority of the Jewish population. In fact they are a very small minority, but, to say they don't exist is simply closing ones eyes to the truth.

      Oh, and... Israel is very important and I get that there is nothing wrong with seeing Israel as important. But being important and being the highest priority for American voters are two very different things.

      If you are an American who believes in most of the things that the President is doing for Americans but you will vote against the President because he implied PM Netanyahu is a pain in the ass DESPITE the fact that the Republicans stand for absolutely NOTHING that you claim is important for America - what do you call that? It's not like President Obama has sided with the Palestinians or the Arab World against Israel. I mean just look at his actual record. Even Bill Kristol (who is as nutty as they come) admits the President has done many good things for Israel.


      As for this:

      The wonks in his employ have focused grouped things to death and know exactly what you have said in this posting - that Jewish voters are not likely to make a large difference to his candidacy.

      I am going to disagree here fiz... I think he realizes that he will only get a small percentage of the Jewish vote (I think 28-30%) but that he is trying to influence Jewish voters in FL where they will make a difference in a close election as well as in PA (Philly area). If he can squeeze a few votes in Florida then he can turn that state. Look at the 2000 election.

      I do have to say though, I think you make a good case for Romney's trying to build up his "evangelical chops".

      I agree with you that Jewish voters are going to break for President Obama and break big. I believe that the Jewish vote will go 70-30 to 72-28 for the President. That said, those extra little points in places like FL and PA can make a difference.

      Delete